You know what you can do well in comics? Scale.
Not to say that they do it expressly well over small, intimate personal stuff. The argument could be made that comics are actually at their best with small, quiet moments. But when I think about things unique to comics, scale is something it has over most other art forms. Because film can do so many things but it’s never able to grasp the huge in the way that comics do. Even massive crowd scenes don’t work the same way as they used to. CGI crowds doesn’t feel the same as several hundred people on a hill listening to Spartacus. The thing about film is it’s most imaginative creators – people like Terry Gilliam, Luc Besson, young Ridley Scott and the like – are straining against budgetary and technological limitations. Comics has creators who think in grandoise fashion. Home to Katushiro Otomo and Geoff Darrow. Brandon Graham and (pre-animation) Miyazaki. Moebius! Jack Kirby! People with ideas so immense they only work in this bastard little medium.
But, interesting as that is, comics excel at producing the strange.
There’s the thing that Grant Morrison has stated – that comics are at their best when they are “even more bizarre, because the one thing comics can do is weirdness and strangeness and surrealism, and they do that better than movies“. Which he calls “lo-fi weirdness”. And they do there’s something just in the basic language of comics that allows for an almost anything to happen without the reader being pulled out of it. Pretty much because we know that it’s just drawings on paper. The ridiculous and the sublime routinely sit side by side, if not in the same instance. Which is why, as stupid as it gets, the silver age stuff still works so well. Those Drake/Premiani Doom Patrol issues are some of the best comics ever made and they make ABSOLUTELY NO SENSE. Taiyo Matsumoto may be more famous for Tenkonkinkreet but fully explodes in No. 5, which reads like The Prisoner by way of Lennon drawings, a Benneton ad, anphetimenes, and the Forever People. I have no idea the context, but the story is profound. Few other art forms could contain Madman, Popbot, Dr. 13, Stray Toasters, Transmetropolitian, Scott Pilgrim, Scary Go Round, Rogan Gosh, G0dland, the exploitation-era 70s marvel books, Seth Fisher, incredibly stupid Legion of Superheroes stories, manga porn, any insane thing you can think of will work because COMICS DON’T NEED TO MAKE SENSE.
And yeah, there’s everything Morrison ever did. Radical changes in scale, dream logic, chaos magic butting up against quantum physics against drug psychosis, religion and time travel and talking animals, death being colorblind, sentient universes being mined for technologies, subway pirates, swarms of death sperm, etc. Morrison is the arbiter of comics-as-chaos, interested in pushing the reader into a new space. His work seeks to elicit an emotional reaction by any means necessary*, be it through profound characterization, structural trickery, or big fuckoff pink goo monster from the disney corporation.
In comics there’s hardly any way to violate the reality of the situation unlike film. Beyond that it’s a visual medium, so concepts which would be difficult for most people to imagine are simply presented the same way as the everyday. And because of this flattened learning curve even the most run of the mill crappy superhero monthly traffics in multiple bizarre and massive ideas. Comics are the place where the impossible makes sense, where scale isn’t a factor. It’s an artform built for big, insane shit.
Doesn’t life need more big, insane shit?
*yeah, and while I’m at it, fuck Tim Callahan and his emotionless detachment.

























































































































11 comments
10/15/2008 at 10:11 pm
Mark Kardwell
Still loving these essays.
Yup, comics do the surreal and the weird and the non sequitur par excellence. The sudden, uncommented upon, shift of tone. The things guys like Luis Bunuel or David Lynch have to work their asses off to achieve in cinema, comics can do with ease, and have done since their inception, with guys like Windsor McKay and George Herriman.
10/15/2008 at 11:38 pm
sean witzke
Fucking exactly. That’s what I was trying to say summed up in 3 sentences.
And thanks, man. This one is a little too short I think.
10/16/2008 at 12:19 am
pillock
Agreed! Film achieves its scale now by becoming a sort of visual collage, that aims at everything looking like it comes from the same place and has the same natural texture…that aims at being seamless…but it can’t quite pull that off. And comics doesn’t need that…but when it drops the collage-stuff in, look out! First time I saw that was in Kirby’s FF, and it freaked me out, because it so wasn’t trying to make all these things look like they had the same texture, it was going the true collage route where they absolutely don’t.
Mind you, I do like it when film manages that seamlessness. But usually it comes from using tricks, doesn’t it?
Whereas when comics puts the same-looking stuff next to each other in panels…in a way I think this is related to comics doing time-travel well, because anything you can read, you can read the same as any other thing you can read…as you say, it’s a flattened learning curve. Hey, like Shane Bailey’s Rip Hunter thing, where time-travel isn’t enough, in comics you can’t even hold anyone’s attention with that, you need ape civilizations in there too…!
But make a TV show out of that, and people’s heads will explode. And that’s just the boring vanilla-flavour comics.
But now you’ve got me thinking about Morrison, who I really think is defined by that “fill-in-the-blanks” thing…interesting that in such a world of comics you describe, where scale is meaningless in the normal sense, he still manages to lose people. Well, that’s what the people who don’t like Morrison always say, that they feel like they’re missing pages, and they don’t get it. So it’s a different conceptual “scale” he’s bringing to the party: you’ve grown accustomed to all these big-ass things, these wild vistas…now I’m going to dose you with acid and make you feel how big it all really is…
Not unlike that Kirby FF collage-stuff, now that I think about it.
Bit of a shorter comment from me this time: I think I’m guilty of having used these other essays’ comment-spaces as places for my own braindumps…very handy, I just have to click the mouse and there I am…
10/16/2008 at 12:19 am
pillock
Whoops, not as short as I thought…!
10/16/2008 at 1:24 am
sean witzke
Hey man, that’s what comments are for. Especially on this crap.
And yeah, Kirby’s (and Sinkeiwicz’s and Steranko’s) mixed media stuff can snap your neck the first time you see it, don’t they? I remember being five and seeing “This Man This Monster” and staring at that page with the spirals for ten minutes.
10/17/2008 at 1:00 am
TimCallahan
“yeah, and while I’m at it, fuck Tim Callahan and his emotionless detachment.”
Heh, this sounds like something my wife will say after the inevitable divorce.
Sean, I love your passion for comics. And I obviously have emotional reactions to comics, but I still think readers who say “______ left me cold” are resorting to a bullshit response. Mostly because they usually say it because they couldn’t “relate” to a character or something like that. For me, the emotion, the joy, the motherfucking glorious thrill of a comic comes not from my connection to the characters, but from the artistry involved in the narrative. From the imagination bursting through the panels. From the high-wire act of a well-tuned structure. That is emotionally vital and exciting, or, if done poorly, devastating.
And yeah, I can separate my emotional reaction from my aesthetic reaction, but one informs the other.
10/17/2008 at 4:05 am
jared
see sean, he can get emotional too! just not about the characters. just sucking the cock of the people who make them!
-J
10/17/2008 at 12:03 pm
Tucker Stone
This is just Tim saying that he didn’t jerk off to Lost Girls.
10/18/2008 at 12:58 am
TimCallahan
Exactly. Or, if I did, it was to the formal experimentation of it. Which was pretty hot.
10/18/2008 at 11:12 pm
Alan Moore
I’d have jerked off more to LOST GIRLS if it had been drawn by Adam Hughes.
10/19/2008 at 1:51 am
sean witzke
I’ll stick with Black Kiss, myself.